Reviews for September. Late, but not as late as the last lot!! I don’t seem to have had a brilliant month in any category.
Nothing pleased me. I watched:
Heartbreak Ridge – with Clint Eastwood as an unlikely army sergeant. **
Kill Bill Two – I missed the beginning and was mystified throughout. I expect it didn’t help that I hadn’t seen the first Kill Bill film. **
Black Lake (ep 1) – I don’t find Scandinavian noir appealing (though I love their police shows) so I didn’t watch any more episodes. **
Nothing gained five stars this month though there was quite a lot of solid and pleasurable reading in the four star list.
The Montana series by RJ Scott ****
1.Crooked Tree Ranch
2.The Rancher’s Son
3.A Cowboy’s Home
These were enjoyable but increasingly improbable. Three families own a ranch and the series follows various family members. Of seven sons, how likely is it that four are gay? There is a sequel relating to the sheriff but I have a severe case of disbelief.
Dragon Prince/Star Scroll/Sunrunner’s Fire by Melanie Rawn****
I was enthusiastic at first – interesting magic, and lovely dragons (who didn’t appear often enough) but by the end of the third book I was frustrated because every time the characters solved a problem another worse one arose, and the huge cast and timeline meant some of my favourite characters were gone. When I gathered that it wasn’t a trilogy but would have further volumes I gave up.
Awfully Glad by Charlie Cochrane****
An enjoyable short novel set just after World War 1. This author is really good at period detail and I liked the way the m/m romance was set against the background of very real fears of being ‘outed’. Well written but personally I prefer her longer series.
And then there was the three star book that took me almost as much time as the others put together…
The Luminaries by Eleanor Catton***
This had so much hype with lots of awards. I’m sure the author’s depiction of the New Zealand gold fields of the nineteenth century was authentic and well researched but I could have read a history book. There wasn’t a single character I cared about, and the mystery was less than enthralling. The structure of the novel, using different points of view, led to a great deal of tedious repetition. Not worth the effort it took to plough through its considerable length.
Nothing to recommend in fanfiction, either. I spent quite a lot of time reading the contributions to the Lewis Summer Challenge and there was some good writing but unless you’re a fan of both the show and the fanfiction, nothing to bring to you.